Appealing a criminal conviction can be a long and arduous road. When you’re facing such a judgment, the process isn’t a simple redo of the trial; it’s more like combing through every legal decision, which can get pretty technical and confusing. This rundown captures the main points of what you need to know when questioning a conviction. If you are convicted of a drug crime and wish to appeal your case, consult a Beaufort drug crimes attorney for assistance.
Schedule Your Free Consultation
Understanding Your Right to Challenge
You may appeal to a higher court if you receive a guilty verdict. You can exercise this right if you notice and point out errors during your trial. While you won’t go through a total retrial, the court will look closely at the procedures followed during the trial.
Speak to a Criminal Defense Lawyer About Your Appeal
You need to speak to a criminal defense lawyer who manages similar cases to ensure the best results in your appeal. They should have experience with the appeal process. If you feel the court made a mistake when deciding on your case, you should express your grievances with an attorney.
Common Reasons for an Appeal
You might appeal your case for the following reasons:
- Legal mistakes – Sometimes, a judge might muddle jury instructions or misinterpret or misapply legal standards to the facts of a case. Any misleading instructions to the jury may cause a flawed verdict. Admitting inadmissible evidence or keeping out evidence that should have been admissible can also lead to an appeal.
- Poor representation – If your initial defense attorney didn’t provide proper representation, it can result in an unfair and wrongful conviction. They may have failed to cross-examine witnesses or follow your instructions correctly. Maybe they did not fully advise you on all the potential implications of a guilty plea, pushing you into a conviction with unexpected consequences. A new criminal defense lawyer can possibly bring an appeal based on ineffective assistance of counsel.
- Prosecution missteps – Occasionally, a prosecutor’s actions can stray into territory that unfairly influences the jury. For example, they can include improper arguments or biases, unfairly influencing the jury. In grave situations, they might withhold key evidence that supports your evidence, and these are highly serious discovery matters called Brady violations.
- Lack of solid evidence – If the proof provided by the prosecutor was not strong enough to warrant, that can be a big red flag. Weak evidence may also call a conviction into question.
- Sentencing errors – Errors might appear even after the trial, especially during sentencing. For instance, the judge may have failed to consider mitigating circumstances. The sentence may also be disproportionate to the defendant's crime or criminal history.
The above examples highlight potential errors in your criminal defense, impacting the fairness of your trial and its results. Errors can lead to a wrongful conviction or a notably harsh sentence.
How the Appeal Process Works
Challenging a conviction isn’t handled in one neat step—it consists of stages with specific guidelines and deadlines. First, you file a Notice of Appeal, which means you intend to contest the verdict.
Then comes the challenging job of assembling the complete trial record (all the documents and transcripts; any missing piece can lead to problems with the appeal). After that, both sides submit briefs, which present written arguments outlining their reasons for requesting a review of the conviction.
If the court schedules an oral argument, your lawyer can present your case and answer questions from the judges. In turn, the appellate court may agree with the conviction, overturn the ruling, or return the case to a lower court.
Time Limitations
You must comply with deadlines. Each part of an appeal comes with deadlines - time limitations that may shift depending on a case’s details. Don’t overlook a deadline. If you make this mistake, the court may dismiss the appeal and deny your chance for a second review.
Review Standards
When the higher court takes a fresh look at your case, it does so based on a certain standard of review. This determines how much credit the original decision received and whether any mistakes made during your trial were serious enough to change the outcome.
Possible Outcomes
After completing all the legal steps, several outcomes can arise. As noted, the court might agree with the original verdict or decide the trial was flawed enough to reverse your conviction. Sometimes, they’ll send the case back down to the lower court for further action.
The decision hinges on whether the errors pointed out are significant enough to warrant a fresh look at the whole process. Sometimes, the higher court follows what the lower court decides, keeping the conviction intact.
Sometimes, if the court finds a glaring mistake in the original ruling, it will reverse the conviction, undoing it due to a serious error that slipped through the legal cracks. There are also occasions when the court remands the case, sending it back to the lower court for further review and additional proceedings. Be aware that statutory limits pertain to remanded orders.
The Role of a Criminal Defense Lawyer
A criminal defense lawyer will explain the legal rules while discussing potential issues in your case. They will keep track of the deadlines and stand up for you in court. You can count on them to protect your rights. Frequently, their know-how of the appeal process makes the difference in whether or not you succeed in your case.
Appealing a verdict is challenging. You must understand the details and factors of your case. You need to speak to a lawyer about appealing your case. By speaking to a competent lawyer who regularly handles appeals, you can work toward a more equitable resolution for your case.
Your attorney will assess the factors of your case and review how they handled the trial. Their review will allow you to decide how to proceed as an appellant.
Consult a Criminal Defense Lawyer Right Away
If you wish to appeal your case, you must talk to a criminal defense lawyer. Work with someone who has experience with appeals for cases just like yours. Take a proactive step now. Contact a criminal defense lawyer.